I thought some fan made the whole "shy" thing up so they could actually find a reason for their paring. But I've never seen him "shy". More like "Painfully generic superhero type", while Amy swings from "Midly desperate" to "Psychotic".
And I'm fairly certain that Sonic Team would bring down the heavens before pairing up these two. And I think I know why: Sonally and how it works in the comics. Seeing what happened in Comic 134 and all the pathetic attempts beyond that, I guess I don't blame them that they're trying to avoid it with Amy.
I never created this. It's an article in a March 2005 issue of "Disney Adventures Magazine", in the section titled "The top 10 gaming mysteries of all time". Under the 'solved' category, question #10 was answered by a member of Sonic Team. So the information provided in this article I cannot answer to, you'd have to take it up with whoever decided to provide the information as a member of Sonic Team. I just uploaded it because some fans wanted to see it.
Also, bear in mind that the comics are not part of the canon -- they are a separate continuity.
I personally don't care either way if Sonamy happens in a game -- I'd rather it didn't because the guessing is more fun, and fans who don't like Sonamy won't end up disappointed.
That said, if you don't like Sonamy, I'm sure we have other things in common as fans. When did you become a Sonic fan? :3